DeMario's Eatery

The Place

Nestled in the charming village of Chittenango in Madison County, DeMario’s Eatery is a hidden gem that’s perfect for those seeking fast, casual, filling, and downright delicious meals. The staff treats every customer like family, and that warmth combines with top-notch quality to earn the place a stellar 4.8 rating. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick lunch, grabbing takeout, or setting up a catering order, the hometown vibe is always there.

The Food

DeMario’s specializes in homemade sandwiches piled high with generous portions of meats, fresh veggies, and flavorful toppings. The beloved BLT, roast beef subs, and grilled cheese are the items locals rave about most. Beyond the sandwiches, the kitchen turns out comforting soups and a baked goods lineup that includes brown butter chocolate chip cookies, half-moon cookies, and pecan cinnamon rolls. Specials rotate through the week — chicken riggies and fish or shrimp on Fridays are worth planning around.

Worth Knowing

Don’t leave without visiting the attached ice cream shop, which is hailed as the best in the area. It’s a sweet finish to any visit, and reason enough to make the trip on its own.